My Doctor Says I Need It. Why Is My Insurance Company Saying No?
You thought your doctor’s order was the decision. Then your insurance company said, “Not yet.”
Your doctor orders an MRI.
Or a medication.
Or a procedure.
You leave the appointment thinking the next step is simple: schedule it, pick it up, get it done.
Then the phone rings.
“We’re waiting for prior authorization.”
Prior what?
Your doctor just said you need it. Isn’t that authorization?
Unfortunately, no.
And this is one of those parts of healthcare many patients don’t understand until they’re caught in the middle of it.
What Is Prior Authorization?
Prior authorization is a process some health insurance companies use before they will cover certain medications, tests, procedures or treatments.
Essentially, the insurance company wants additional information showing that the requested care meets its requirements for coverage.
That doesn’t necessarily mean the insurance company is saying you don’t need the care.
It means they’re saying:
“Before we agree to pay for this, we need more information or certain criteria must be met.”
For patients, however, that distinction can feel pretty meaningless when you’re the one waiting.
Why Does My Insurance Company Get a Say?
This is the question patients understandably ask.
Insurance companies use prior authorization partly to control costs and make sure treatments meet their coverage guidelines.
But prior authorization has also become a significant source of frustration for doctors, healthcare staff and patients because it can create additional paperwork and delays before treatment begins.
And this is where the patient can get lost.
Your doctor is thinking about what they believe you need medically.
Your insurance company is determining whether that care meets the requirements of your particular plan.
Those are two different decisions.
And unfortunately, you are standing between them.
“We’re Waiting for Authorization”
I’ve heard patients repeat this sentence without really knowing what it means.
They’ve been waiting a week.
Maybe two.
They assume somebody is handling it.
Sometimes they don’t even know which office they’re waiting for.
If you hear the words prior authorization, don’t be afraid to ask what happens next.
Who is submitting it?
Has it already been submitted?
Does the insurance company need additional information?
How long does the process usually take?
Who should you call if you haven’t heard anything?
You don’t need to understand the entire insurance system.
You just need to understand your next step.
A Denial Doesn’t Always Mean It’s Over
This is important.
If an insurance company denies authorization, find out why.
Sometimes additional documentation is needed.
Sometimes the insurer requires another treatment to be tried first.
Sometimes the requested medication isn’t on the plan’s preferred drug list.
Sometimes the healthcare provider can appeal the decision or request a discussion with the insurer about why the treatment is medically necessary.
The options depend on the insurance plan and the situation, but don’t hear the word denied and automatically assume there is nothing else you can do.
Ask:
“What is the reason for the denial, and what are our options now?”
That’s a very different question from simply accepting no.
Don’t Quietly Wait If You’re Getting Worse
This is where I put my nurse hat on.
Insurance paperwork is one thing.
Your health is another.
If you’re waiting for authorization and your symptoms are worsening, tell your healthcare provider.
Don’t assume the office knows.
Don’t assume the insurance company understands that something has changed.
And don’t sit at home getting progressively sicker because someone told you the authorization is still pending.
If symptoms become severe or you believe you’re experiencing an emergency, seek appropriate medical care.
Administrative delays should never become a reason to ignore a significant change in your condition.
Ask Before You Leave the Appointment
One of the simplest things patients can do is ask early.
When your doctor orders an expensive medication, imaging study, procedure or other treatment, ask:
“Does my insurance need to authorize this first?”
The person in front of you may not know immediately.
That’s okay.
The point is to get the process moving.
You might also ask whether there is anything you need to do and whom you should contact if you haven’t heard back.
A five-minute conversation today may save you days of confusion later.
You Shouldn’t Have to Be an Insurance Expert
This is one of the frustrating realities of modern healthcare.
Patients are already expected to understand diagnoses, medications, appointments, test results and discharge instructions.
Then we add deductibles, networks, referrals, formularies and prior authorizations.
Most people didn’t learn any of this until they became sick.
And being sick is a terrible time to learn a complicated system.
You don’t need to know everything.
But you do need to know when to ask questions.
If your doctor recommends something and suddenly you’re told the insurance company hasn’t approved it, don’t simply walk away confused.
Ask what is happening.
Ask who is responsible for the next step.
Ask when you should follow up.
And if the answer is no, ask why.
Because sometimes navigating healthcare isn’t about knowing the entire system.
It’s about knowing the next question to ask.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Prior Authorization and Interoperability.
American Medical Association. Prior Authorization.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Health Insurance and Prior Authorization.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Appealing a Health Plan Decision.