Trusting Your Gut in Healthcare Decisions
A checklist for patients and families facing complex or confusing medical choices
Before Making a Big Medical Decision
- Have I taken a pause to reflect, not just react?
- Do I fully understand the diagnosis and the proposed treatment?
- Have I asked, “Are there any other options?”
- Have I written down or recorded questions to ask my provider?
- Have I brought someone with me to help listen, take notes, or advocate?
Asking Questions That Matter
- What are the risks and benefits of this option?
- What happens if we wait or try something else first?
- How will this treatment affect my daily life, independence, or long-term function?
- What would you do if this were your loved one in my shoes?
- Can you explain that in a simpler way or provide something in writing?
Considering a Second (or Third) Opinion
- Have I been encouraged to get a second opinion—or do I feel okay asking for one?
- Have I heard more than one approach to this diagnosis or problem?
- Have I looked for someone with a different specialty or care philosophy (e.g., surgical vs. non-surgical)?
- Do I understand the consensus and the variations among doctors?
- Does one explanation or plan align more clearly with my values or goals?
Checking in With Your Gut
- Does this provider listen to me, or talk past me?
- Do I feel rushed, dismissed, or intimidated in appointments?
- Does this treatment plan make sense to me, even if it’s hard?
- Have I had time to reflect, without feeling pressured?
- If something feels “off,” have I taken it seriously?
Personal Advocacy & Support
- Have I asked someone I trust to be my healthcare partner or advocate?
- Have I joined a support group or found others who’ve faced similar decisions?
- Am I keeping a simple health journal—questions, test results, changes in how I feel?
- Do I know how to access my medical records and test results?
You don’t have to be a doctor to make a wise health decision.
You just have to be informed, curious, and courageous enough to listen—to the people who care for you, yes, but also to yourself.